Council Tax - high-value property bands (mansion tax): consultation analysis
Analysis of responses to the Council Tax high-value property bands consultation, which ran from 19 May to 24 August 2026. The consultation sought views on proposed rates for two new bands: Band I for properties valued between £1 million and £2 million and Band J for properties valued over £2 million
Executive Summary
A public consultation on illustrative rate proposals for Council Tax High-Value Property Bands (Mansion Tax) ran from 6 July 2026 to 24 August 2026. It asked respondents to consider proposed illustrative rates for the two new Council Tax Bands: Band I and Band J. It also provided an open question where respondents were able to comment on anything else not covered in the two quantitative questions. Public consultations invite everyone to express their views; individuals and organisations interested in the topic are more likely to respond than those without a direct or known interest. This self-selection means the views of respondents do not necessarily represent the views of the entire population.
With regard to the quantitative questions, respondents expressed mixed views about the proposed relative tax bands. Over half of respondents answering (55%) supported a relative tax rate lower than the proposed 2.886 for Band I. In contrast, a quarter of respondents answering (25%) felt it should be higher and just under a sixth (14%) supported the proposed rate. These results are almost identical to the responses to Question 2 regarding the proposed relative tax rate of 4.628 for Band J (55% of respondents answering were in favour of a lower tax rate, 25% supported a higher rate and 13% supported the proposed rate).
In responses to both questions, organisations were more likely than individuals to support higher relative rates, as were respondents who self-identified as having homes in Council Tax Bands A-D. In contrast, those who reported having homes in Council Tax Bands E-H supported lower relative tax rates for both of the new bands.
Four fifths of all respondents answered the open question. Many of these responses focused less on the relative rates of the proposed new bands and more on the implementation and potential impacts of the two new bands. Many respondents highlighted concerns around affordability, primarily for groups who may find themselves in more expensive homes but have less disposable income, such as pensioners or larger families. Interest in, or calls for, wider council tax reform was also noted by many respondents, regardless of whether or not they supported the proposed rates.
Several respondents raised questions or concerns around the proposed rates, the rate calculation or the band valuations, and several other respondents were concerned about the potential impact of introducing the two new bands on Scotland’s economy.
Themes raised by some or fewer respondents included, from most to least prevalent:
- Questions and concerns about the impacts of the new tax bands across different local authority areas
- Concern that the administrative costs may outweigh the benefits of the new bands.
- Agreement with the introduction of the bands and support for the proposed rates, or higher rates, on homes over £1 million
- Calls for a transparent and fair valuation process with pathways for appeals.
Contact
Email: LocalTax@gov.scot