Children's Hearing Advocacy Group Meeting: expert reference group minute: July 2026

Minutes from the meeting of the group on 9 July 2026


Attendees and apologies

Attendees

Audrey Clark, Chair, Scottish Government
Alison Heron, Law Society of Scotland
Annmarie Denny, East Ayrshire Advocacy Services
Claire Grant, Scottish Government
Caroline McDonald, Social Work Scotland
Jayne Brinded, Partners in Advocacy
Kirsty Bradshaw-McLeish, Borders Independent Advocacy Service
Sarah Bannerman, Clan Childlaw
Gordon Main, Scottish Children’s Report Administration
Elaine Adams, Centre for Excellence for Children’s Care and Protection
Mel McDonald, Children’s Hearings Scotland
Melissa Hunt, Scottish Children’s Report Administration
Jane Crawford, CAPS Independent Advocacy
Julie Hutton, Independent Advocacy Perth and Kinross
Lauren Platt, Scottish Government
Louise Piaskowski, Scottish Government
Sarah Fogg, Independent Advocacy Perth and Kinross
Selwyn McCausland, Barnardo’s


Apologies

Alicja Piliszczuk, Borders Independent Advocacy Service
Avril Muir, Angus Independent Advocacy
Ian Macrae, Advocacy Western Isles
Kay McKerrell, Who Cares? Scotland
Ross Gibson, Children and Young People’s Centre for Justice
Tom McNamara,Scottish Government

The chair gave special mention to the following attendees:

Sarah Bannerman, Clan Childlaw – new project lead
Caroline McDonald, Social Work Scotland new representative (previously Vivien Thompson)
Alison Heron, Child and Family Law sub-committee Member, Law Society of Scotland (previously Amerdeep Kaur)
Kirsty Bradshaw-McLeish, Borders Independent Advocacy Service (BIAS), Assistant Service Manager in place of Alicja

Items and actions

Items and actions

This note provides an overview of the agenda, discussion, and action points from the meeting of the Children’s Hearings Advocacy Expert Reference Group (ERG). Once agreed by members the meeting note will be published. 

The meeting was held in remotely, enabling participants to join via Microsoft Teams. Papers issued for this meeting included: the agenda; minute of the last meeting 29 January 2026; Scottish Government (SG) update paper; Scottish Children’s Reporter Administration (SCRA) update papers; NPN update and Terms of Reference for the group.

Agenda item two – minutes and actions from previous meetings

The Chair invited any changes to the draft note of the 29 January 2026 meeting. No changes were made, the note was agreed, and it was confirmed it will be published on the Scottish government website.

The Chair provided an update on the actions and activity from the last meeting.

Action one

Wording change on website question around parental permission to advocacy
support. Kay to lead discussion on the revision of the website question text at the NPN and report back to ERG on outcome.

Suggested revised wording:-

If you would like advocacy support but a parent/carer will not give their permission, the children’s hearing can help. You can either tell the children’s panel members yourself, or ask an adult, such as a social worker, carer, or teacher to raise this at your next children's hearing.

Update: Kay and Scottish government have progressed this. The revised wording was shared at this meeting and discussed. Members requested time to consider this and share views after the meeting.

Action two

Clan Childlaw training dates - Vicki to update on future Clan Childlaw training dates for children’s hearings advocacy workers when available.

Update: Sarah Bannerman has provided a written update included in the Scottish government Update paper for today’s meeting and will give an oral update under members business agenda item.

Action three

Development of a qualification - Scottish government - Pam/Louise to contact Holly Lambert and team to take forward training and qualification discussion.

Update: Audrey and Louise continue to keep this on work plans and in linkages with Hollie and team on development and commencement plans for the Children (Care, Care Experienced, and Services Planning) (Scotland) Act 2026.

Action four

Data analysis - Scottish government to share the draft discussion paper prepared for the Data analysis subgroup meeting held in January 2026.

Update: Note of the meeting was shared in the meeting papers.

Action five

Children’s Hearings Improvement Partnership (CHIP) - Scottish government to send February 2026 Redesign engagement event invitation to ERG members.

Update: Completed.

Action six

Remit of the ERG/Terms of Reference (TOR)

Update: Draft TOR and membership were included in the papers for feedback and discussion under agenda item 5.

Action seven

Date of next ERG - Scottish government to send the next ERG meeting details in a diary invite.

Update: Completed.

Agenda Item three – Member updates

The Chair invited members to give updates.

Scottish Children’s Reporter Administration (SCRA) Update - Melissa Hunt

Melissa shared that there is a new child and young people communication tools being rolled out after the summer. This is called Communicrate and the SCRA corporate parenting manager offered time to discuss this project with any members who have questions.

Written Update Papers were shared in advance, including:

•SCRA quarterly and 3 year data report on advocacy in Children’s Hearings

Melissa advised that Ayrshire and Grampian regions are exploring opportunities to engage with children and young people at an earlier stage in the grounds hearing process, and that advocacy workers may be invited to participate.

Julie Hutton asked Melissa to clarify which areas are included within the Grampian approach, specifically whether this covers both the East and North areas.

Melissa confirmed the initiative will cover the whole of Aberdeen, however, implementation may not take place across all areas simultaneously.

Children’s Hearings Scotland (CHS) Update

Mel McDonald advised that there are no major updates at present. CHS in collaboration with SCRA are currently rolling out the ‘Postcard’ initiative to all nine localities by the end of the year following the pilot scheme across Grampian, Ayrshire, Glasgow and Tayside. The Chair of each hearing will provide the child or young person involved with the Postcard that has a QR code, inviting them to share feedback on their experience of the hearing process.

The aim of the pilot is to gather meaningful feedback directly from children and young people to help CHS identify opportunities for improvement and ensure the hearings system is as child-centred as possible. Mel encouraged advocacy workers to support children and young people to engage with the initiative. Feedback from advocacy workers themselves is also welcomed.

CHS is also undertaking a redesign of its website to make it more child-focused and accessible for young people. As part of this work, a short online survey will be launched to gather feedback from children and young people on the current website and identify areas for improvement. The findings will inform the redesign, with the updated website expected to be launched towards the end of summer 2026.

National Providers Network (NPN)

Kay McKerrell provided a written update for this agenda item. The topics included legislative implementation, engagement with agencies, provider experience and matters for the wider ERG. The Chair invited members to raise any questions or comments on the update. None were received.

Clan Childlaw

Sarah Bannerman provided an update from Clan Childlaw. Training for 2026 has commenced and the second round of training will take place in January and February 2027. Dates have been circulated to all advocacy organisations and there have already been a number of sign-ups. Sarah clarified the refresher training three topic sessions and three topics/sessions must be completed in the year.

Sarah will attend the NPN meeting on 16 July and collate feedback from the recent cross-border training event.

As always, Sarah asked that any new advocacy workers be put in contact with Clan Childlaw where appropriate.

Children’s Hearings Redesign

Elaine Adams provided an update on Children’s Hearings Redesign Programme and the workstream activity. The Children’s Hearings Redesign Board’s purpose and meeting minutes are published on the Scottish government website. The Board have met twice to look at the progress and risk of the Children (Care, Care-Experienced and Services Planning) (Scotland) Act 2026 risks and evaluation framework. An update for each of the four workstream subgroups was given:

•Culture – an in-person workshop took place in June to discuss the principles
document. The group have also met with Gordon at Our hearings Our Voice.
•Planning and Preparation for Hearings – the group are currently looking at how changes can be made to happen and discussed with the Children’s Hearings Improvement Partnership (CHIP) group. 
•Referral – moving at pace – the group have been meeting with learning leads within SCRA to develop digital resources on legislation and practice and the latest wave includes work on storyboards for Compulsory Supervision Orders, Child Protection Orders and emergency transfers.
•Data – information requested on the types of data held by organisations across the hearings system is being collated to build a clearer picture of the data landscape. It is intended the work of this group will take place over several years.

There will be a second Hearings Redesign Engagement Event in the Autumn, and details will be shared with all partners when the arrangements are set.

Our Hearings, Our Voice (OHOV)

Gordon Main provided an update from OHOV. He noted that young people had been invited to attend the passing of the Children (Care, Care Experienced and Services Planning) Bill in Parliament, which had been a very positive experience for those involved.

Gordon also advised work is underway to explore accreditation opportunities for young people who wish to be involved in future participation work. There is also work to influence business around the guide on how adults should behave including through CHIP and on relevant boards where appropriate. Gordon asked members
with direct contact with children and young people to help share information about OHOV members recruitment.

Over the summer, OHOV will be working with young people on children's rights. Current feedback suggests that support and information are not always readily available. Gordon invited any organisations interested in contributing to this work to raise this through the CHAMPS Board.

Caroline McDonald suggested that the Glasgow CHAMPS group be contacted. Gordon confirmed that he was already scheduled to meet with them later that
afternoon.

Action

•Scottish government to circulate the OHOV recruitment flyer with members.

Scottish Government Update

A written update was provided to members prior to the meeting. As well as this,Louise Piaskowki gave a verbal update which included:

Funding

•Total cost for children’s hearings advocacy provision £1.97m for 2025-26, raised budget (to £2.2m) for 2026-27 primarily for expansion for the cross-border placements advocacy. Year 2 of the multi-year Fairer Funding imitative.

Children Care & Justice (Scotland) Act 2024

•The third set of regulations came into force in March, introducing measures to support more age-appropriate approaches to police custody, as well as a framework for considering court adaptations for children.
•A consultation on the SPOC service closed on 16 April. Initial internal analysis has been completed and independent analysis has been commissioned, with findings expected in late July or early August.
•We will be reaching out to advocacy organisations to plan for expansion of advocacy services to support young people in respect of their hearings resulting from the raise in age of referral to the Principal Reporter.
•The Children (Care, Care Experience and Services Planning) (Scotland) Act came into force in May 2026.
•Officials are working on sequencing in order to properly implement all the provisions in a planned and coherent way. This will be taken forward with key delivery partners and further engagement and work as mentioned in the written update will be progressed.

Secure care Consultation

•A public consultation on the future of secure care ended on 16 April. It covered a range of potential reforms, including options for nationalisation and national co-ordination of secure care, as well as consideration of alternative provision. Fifty plus responses were received and an independent analysis of responses will now be undertaken. We anticipate the analysis report being available in Autumn.

Training/Cross Boarder Placements

•Clan Childlaw and Scottish Government residential Childcare Team colleagues have been invited to the next NPN meeting on 16 July to discuss training and legal support services, and cross border placements advocacy offer practice matters in more detail.

Members were asked if they had any questions regarding this update. None were given.

Agenda item four - Data analysis discussion

The Chair opened the item for discussion

Louise Piaskowski thanked SCRA for the work undertaken in preparing data reports. She reminded members it had been agreed at the previous meeting the sub-group discussion paper would be circulated and invited views on whether the data was being used effectively.

Selwyn McCausland advised the NPN subgroup had met and felt the purpose of the analysis needed to be clearer. He queried whether lower levels of advocacy demand in some areas reflected lower awareness or uptake of services. He also asked how the data was being used in practice, noting that all organisations were operating under pressure and wanted to ensure resources were being used effectively. Selwyn emphasised the importance of understanding the value of reporting requirements if the information gathered was not leading to action.

Sarah Fogg expressed an interest in how the SCRA data related to children and young people accessing legal aid. She highlighted recent changes relating to virtual legal representation at hearings and raised concerns that, if solicitors were less willing to travel, some children and young people could be left without appropriate support. Sarah noted the importance of monitoring this issue going forward.

Melissa Hunt clarified the SCRA data presented were focused on children and young people involved in the Children's Hearings System. She confirmed data would also be collected on solicitors instructed directly by parents but support for parents is not
part of the reports.

Annmarie Denny noted some children and young people had transferred between advocacy providers, which may affect the accuracy of the figures.

Caroline McDonald asked whether the data included a breakdown between welfare and offence grounds. Melissa advised that, due to the low number of cases on offence grounds, this breakdown was not currently provided and may not be overly useful. She noted legislative changes coming for raising the age of referral to the Principal Reporter may see this shift.

Kirsty Bradshaw-McLeish asked whether, if a young person moved to a different local authority area, the data would remain linked to the original area or transfer to the new one. Louise confirmed that this information would be available through grant monitoring returns.

Agenda item five - Remit of the ERG

A revised draft Terms of Reference paper supported this discussion.

The Chair opened the discussion by asking members if there had any comments on the revised terms of reference noting this reflects a move from implementation to on-going strategic oversight, as well as drawing in the cross-border placement advocacy. The Chair ask whether there were any additional individuals or organisations that should be represented within the ERG going forward.

Selwyn McCausland noted the introduction of the new Children (Care, Care Experienced and Services Planning) Act 2026 may require changes to the group's membership and remit and suggested that this should be explored further e.g. to include Police. However, he emphasised the importance of retaining the ERG as a forum.

Caroline McDonald advised she is currently exploring learning and development opportunities for colleagues within the National Social Work Agency and noted there may be interest from them in becoming involved with the ERG.

Sarah Fogg asked how the ERG agenda compared with that of CHIP, and whether there was significant overlap between the two groups. Louise explained that advocacy providers are not individually represented on CHIP and noted that CHIP itself is currently under review.

The Chair thanked members for their contributions and confirmed that consideration of the ERG's membership and purpose would remain an ongoing discussion.

Action

•All members to share any views with Scottish Government on purpose and
composition of the group. This item will be carried forward to the agenda for the next meeting.

Agenda item six – Any other Business

The Chair asked members if they wished to raise any other business. Nothing was
raised.

Agenda item seven - date of next meeting

The provisional date of the next meeting will be Tuesday 17 November 2026 and a calendar hold will be sent.

Action

•Scottish Government to send the next ERG meeting details in a diary invite.

Back to top