Further publication of judicial review advice

Release of documents to assist committee inquiry.

Additional legal advice documents relating to the judicial review brought by Alex Salmond have been published by the Scottish Government.

The publication of these documents follows the decision to release key legal advice in the handling of the judicial review to disprove allegations made about the Scottish Government’s handling.

Deputy First Minister John Swinney said:

“The Scottish Government decided it was necessary to take the exceptional step of releasing key legal advice to ensure the public could have confidence that legal advice was not ignored or the process deliberately delayed.

“The documents released today should enhance that public confidence.

“In particular it is clear that delaying the case – known as sisting - was only considered as an option in order to minimise the impact of the case on the ongoing police investigation. This option was explicitly ruled out by the Lord Advocate who made clear that it was ‘preferable and appropriate’ that court-imposed reporting restrictions protect the integrity of any future prosecution.

“This puts beyond any doubt that there was any attempt to delay the judicial review so that it would be overtaken by criminal proceedings.

“I have instructed officials to consider whether further documents should be released, subject to essential statutory checks and notifications, and to do so as a matter of urgency.”


The documents are available at: Judicial review advice published by Ministers - gov.scot (www.gov.scot)

The documents the Scottish Government is making available to the Inquiry cover the key advice from external Counsel that informed decisions at critical points in the progress of the judicial review, in particular around the prospects of success. 

The latest release follows the completion of notifications that the Scottish Government was required to make in terms of the General Data Protection Regulation.



Media enquiries

Back to top