Publication - FOI/EIR release

Breakdown of planning application appeals since 2011: EIR release

Information request and response under the Environmental Information (Scotland) Regulations 2004

Published:
16 Jun 2021
Breakdown of planning application appeals since 2011: EIR release
FOI reference: FOI/202100207520
Date received: 27 May 2021
Date responded: 15 Jun 2021
Information requested

1. In the calendar years 2011-2021 how many appeals, of all types have you received from the following companies:

  • Teague Group
  • S1 Developments
  • MNM Developments
  • Glencairn Properties

2. Of these appeals, how many were for:

  • Residential use
  • Purpose Built Student Accommodation
  • Commercial use
  • A mix of all three
  • Other usage

3. Of these appeals how many of these have been approved by the Reporter? Please provide detail by proposal type:

  • Residential use
  • Purpose Built Student Accommodation
  • Commercial use
  • A mix of all three
  • Other usage

4. Can you give details behind the decision to approve the appeals for Case References PPA-230-2323 & PPA-230-2298?

Response

1-3. Please see below a table which contains the details you requested.

Case Ref

Appellant

Date Case Received

Site Address

Case Detail

Decision Description

Type

PPA- 50- 2151

S1 Developments Ltd

10/12/2012

St Ford House, Liberty, Elie, Leven Fife

Erection of two semi detached dwellinghouses

Appeal Allowed

Housing/Residential

POA-230- 2003

S1 Developments Ltd

23/03/2015

4 Ellersley Road, Edinburgh, EH12 6HZ

Modification Of Planning Obligation To Amend Affordable Housing Financial Contribution Associated With Planning Application 06/05170/Ful

Appeal Dismissed

Housing/Residential

Case Ref

Appellant

Date Case Received

Site Address

Case Detail

Decision Description

Type

PPA-230- 2227

Glencairn Properties

25/05/2018

7 Gf, 7 1F, 8, 10, 10A And 10B, Lower Gilmore Place, Edinburgh, EH3 9NY

Demolition Of All Buildings On Site And Erection Of Office (Class 4) And Flatted Residential Development With Associated Car Parking Landscaping And Public Realm

Appeal Dismissed

mix of residential and commercial

PPA-230- 2289

Glencairn Properties

17/10/2019

7Gf, 71F, 8, 10, 10A & 10B Lower Gilmore Place, Edinburgh, EH3 9NY

Demolition Of All Buildings On Site And Erection Of Office (Class 4) And Flatted Residential Development With Associated Car Parking And Landscaping

(20 Residential Units)

Appeal Allowed

Mix of residential and commercial

Case Ref

Appellant

Date Case Received

Site Address

Case Detail

Decision Description

Type

PPA-230- 2304

Teague Homes (UK) Ltd

05/03/2020

Former 9 - 21 Salamander Place, Edinburgh, EH6 7JB

5No. New Parking Places In Lieu Of Parking And Mews Building Structure (2No Dwellings) Forming Part Of Planning Consent Ref. 16/03356/Ppp. (As Amended)

No Jurisdiction to consider

Other

4. In terms of your query regarding details behind the decision to approve the appeals for Case reference PPA-230-2323 and PPA-230-2298, the reporter(s) record the extent and scope of their reasoning for their decision, within the decision notices. I attach, for convenience, a link to those decision notices below. If it may help further I attach, for interest, a link to our guidance on taking part in the appeals process https://www.gov.scot/publications/planning-and-environmental-appealsdivision-guidance-on-taking-part-in-planning-appeals-and-other-cases/

PPA-230-2323 - https://www.dpea.scotland.gov.uk/Document.aspx?id=739702

PPA-230-2298 - https://www.dpea.scotland.gov.uk/Document.aspx?id=669107

About FOI
The Scottish Government is committed to publishing all information released in response to Freedom of Information requests. View all FOI responses at http://www.gov.scot/foi-responses.

Contact

Please quote the FOI reference
Central Enquiry Unit
Email: ceu@gov.scot
Phone: 0300 244 4000

The Scottish Government
St Andrews House
Regent Road
Edinburgh
EH1 3DG