Razor clams - commercial fishery using electric current gear: consultation analysis - equality impact assessment

Equality impact assessment (EQIA) for the consultation on a commercial fishery for razor clams using electric current gear in Scottish waters.


Key Findings

Key findings: Age

We hold information on the date of birth of divers active in the trial but otherwise do not hold information on workers age in this fleet segment. Policy officials’ engagement with participants highlights there are issues relating to age that we learn of when facilitating a change in ownership of a vessel between family members, but this has not been systematically analysed. We recognise this means we make an assessment here on incomplete data and have used judgement based on our working relationship with fishers in the trial in recognition of this gap in our data holdings.

Eliminating unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation

No impact. This policy establishes a limited commercial fishery following the scientific trial, and as such we do not identify a way in which options could have positive or negative effects on unlawful age discrimination. No consultation or workshop respondents identified any negative impacts associated with Age.

Advancing equality of opportunity

Positive impact. We note that the extended duration of the scientific trial has led in some cases to business owners reaching retirement age.

The commercial fishery framework may provide opportunities for future entry by younger participants should additional opportunities become available through future management decisions.

This being said we have no insight into the likely age profile of any new entrants and recognise the prevailing trend in inshore fishing in Scotland is an ageing workforce.

We would expect this positive impact to mainly be possible for masters, owners and crew, rather than divers who are already generally younger than fishers at large due to the health and fitness requirements of the occupation.

Several fishing industry respondents to the consultation argued that a commercial fishery could support young fishers and future entrants to the fishing industry.

Promoting good relations among and between different age groups

Positive impact. The consultation outcome of a commercial fishery will settle the permanent status of fishing for razor clams. We identify this as making employment in this fleet segment less precarious, and therefore allowing more opportunity for experienced staff to remain and train younger entrants, raising its visibility as a career among young people.

Key findings: Disabilities

We have no information on participation in razor clam fishing by people with disabilities. No national-level data are available covering the contemporary fishing industry workforce. We base our assessment on the nature of the work, which in our judgement is likely to mean opportunities are highly limited for people with disabilities. We do not consider the policy itself to materially change PSED aspects in relation to this characteristic. We did receive feedback to our consultation that the layout was difficult to navigate, with information spread across different pages. This was described as problematic for people with memory issues, ADHD or brain fog. This related to the consultation facility itself rather than the matters presented.

Eliminating unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation

No impact. This policy establishes a limited commercial fishery following the scientific trial, and as such we do not identify a way in which options could have positive or negative effects on unlawful disability discrimination.

Advancing equality of opportunity

No impact. Fishing is unfortunately difficult for people with disabilities to practice commercially, particularly where it involves diving. This proposal does not change this fact in a positive or negative direction.

We note vessel owners have a duty to hold insurance in the event of workplace related serious injury or disability and this policy does not affect this.

Promoting good relations among and between different age groups

No impact. It is unlikely that this policy will have an effect on promoting good relations between disabled and non-disabled people as we do not consider this activity to be open to disabled people in any meaningful sense. This is unfortunately a result of the physical and worker safety barriers to greater participation that apply to fishing in general, and fishing with divers in particular.

Key findings: Sex

We have some information on the sex of workers in the current scientific trial but this does not encompass the entire workforce. We have information on the sex breakdown of workers in the catching and onshore sectors for the fishing industry as a whole in Scotland. We base our assessment on the assumption participation by women is low (albeit likely to be higher than the sector-wide rate) and judge that issues identified as relevant to the sector as a whole are likely to apply to this fleet segment in a similar way. We do not consider the policy itself to materially change any PSED aspects relating to this characteristic.

Eliminating unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation

No impact. We recognise that fishing does present challenges to women and there are persistent sexist attitudes in the sector as a whole, however we have no information on how or if this manifests in the razor clam fleet.

We do not identify a way that this policy would make the existing problems relating to discrimination better or worse.

Advancing equality of opportunity

No impact. Fishing tends to be male dominated; in the Scottish catching sector, 0.5% of workers are female.

In the razor clam fleet, we know of one vessel owner and dive contractor who is female, meaning the equivalent labour participation rate at a minimum is approximately 1%. This is not a level that is cause for celebration but we note that it is an improvement on the sector-wide statistic.

While we recognise this is a structural issue in commercial fishing, this proposal is not considered to make this imbalance in equality of opportunity any better or worse.

Promoting good relations among and between different age groups

No impact. We recognise that in Scotland there is a division of labour in fishing where women are more often working in onshore capacities or in uncompensated activities like childcare. These are documented to be undervalued.

We do not anticipate this policy materially changing this structural issue in fishing.

Key findings: Pregnancy and maternity

We do not have any data on this characteristic in relation to razor clam fishing businesses, nor are we aware of any national-level data. As the majority of people working on small vessels earn money through crew-share arrangements rather than salaried income, we make the assessment on the basis that maternity earnings of new mothers working in this area are likely to be no greater than statutory entitlements. We do not identify a mechanism by which this policy could affect any PSED aspect in relation to this characteristic.

Eliminating unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation

No impact. This policy establishes a limited commercial fishery following the scientific trial, and as such we do not identify a way in which options could have positive or negative effects on unlawful pregnancy discrimination.

We note that there are existing regulatory requirements as they relate to working conditions for new and expectant mothers working in fishing and this policy does not override these.

Advancing equality of opportunity

No impact. In common with much of the inshore fishing sector, a significant portion of the workforce is casualised and therefore the likelihood is that maternity pay would be restricted in many circumstances to statutory allowances. This policy does not make this issue any better or worse, though we note that the outcome to move to a commercial fishery may galvanise professionalisation of the workforce in some cases that may improve maternity pay.

Promoting good relations among and between different age groups

No impact. This policy is not considered to have any positive or negative effect on promoting good relations between pregnant people and others.

Key findings: Gender reassignment

We have no data on this characteristic relating to razor clam vessel workforce, nor are we aware of any national-level data on the fishing fleet as a whole. Our assessment is based on failing to identify a mechanism by which this policy could affect any PSED aspect of this characteristic.

Eliminating unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation

No impact. This policy establishes a limited commercial fishery following the scientific trial, and as such we do not identify a way in which options could have positive or negative effects on unlawful gender reassignment discrimination.

Advancing equality of opportunity

No impact. No data exist on trans people in the fishing workforce in Scotland, however we do not consider this policy as likely to place any additional barriers or incentives for greater participation by this group.

Promoting good relations among and between different age groups

No impact. This policy is not considered to have any positive or negative effect on promoting good relations between trans people and cisgender people.

Key findings: Sexual orientation

We have no data on this characteristic relating to razor clam vessel workforce, nor are we aware of any national-level data on the fishing fleet as a whole. Our assessment is based on failing to identify a mechanism by which this policy could affect any PSED aspect of this characteristic.

Eliminating unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation

No impact. This policy establishes a limited commercial fishery following the scientific trial, and as such we do not identify a way in which options could have positive or negative effects on unlawful sexual orientation discrimination.

Advancing equality of opportunity

No impact. No contemporary data exist on sexual orientation of people in the fishing workforce in Scotland, however we do not identify a mechanism through which this policy could place any additional barriers or incentives for greater participation by this group.

Promoting good relations among and between different age groups

No impact. This policy is not considered to have any positive or negative effect on promoting good relations between people of different sexual orientations.

Key findings: Race

We do not hold information on race or nationality of crew or divers. Our assessment is based on failing to identify a mechanism by which this policy could affect any PSED aspect of this characteristic.

Eliminating unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation

No impact. This consultation is about transitioning from the current scientific trial to another status, and as such we do not identify a way in which options could have positive or negative effects on unlawful race discrimination.

Advancing equality of opportunity

No impact. We do not have information no the nationality or race of divers or crew involved in fishing for razor clams so cannot determine if there is a positive or negative impact of establishing a fishery.

Promoting good relations among and between different age groups

No impact. We have no data on the nationality or race of crew and divers in the scientific trial, however we may expect the skilled work and reliance on each other required to fish for razor clams to foster good relations, where crew of different nationalities and races work together.

We received a consultation response relating to the use of remote electronic monitoring and using this on what were characterised as illegal European fishers targeting razor clams. This suggests there is a good relations risk to be managed, however no non-UK vessels have ever held permission to fish for razor clams through the scientific trial.

Key findings: Religion or belief

We have no data on this characteristic relating to razor clam vessel workforce, nor are we aware of any national-level data on the fishing fleet as a whole. Our assessment is based on failing to identify a mechanism by which this policy could affect any PSED aspect of this characteristic.

Eliminating unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation

No impact. This policy establishes a limited commercial fishery following the scientific trial, and as such we do not identify a way in which options could have positive or negative effects on unlawful religion or belief discrimination.

Advancing equality of opportunity

No impact. We recognise there are cultural and ethnographic reasons why one religion or another may be more prevalent in different areas around Scotland and correspondingly in the local fishing fleet, but do not consider this policy to be likely to affect this characteristic.

We do not identify a mechanism by which any option considered in the consultation could have a positive or negative effect on equality of opportunity for people of different beliefs.

Promoting good relations among and between different age groups

No impact. This policy is not considered to have any positive or negative effect on promoting good relations between people of different religions.

Key findings: Marriage and civil partnership

We have no data on this characteristic relating to razor clam vessel workforce, nor are we aware of any national-level data on the fishing fleet as a whole. Analysis suggests there is a significant intersection between career opportunities for women in fishing, particularly the catching sector, and marriage and civil partnership status. We assess that this policy is unlikely to affect PSED aspects in relation to this characteristic.

Eliminating unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation

No impact. This policy establishes a limited commercial fishery following the scientific trial, and as such we do not identify a way in which options could have positive or negative effects on unlawful marriage or civil partnership discrimination.

Advancing equality of opportunity

No impact. We recognise there are nuanced and intersecting issues with regard to marriage and civil partnership in the fishing industry as a whole: marriage to a fisher appears to offer industry access and earning potential that may be unavailable to single women, however analysis suggests this comes with sex-related labour expectations – onshore work, unpaid childcare. We do not have information on the extent to which this pattern is replicated in this fleet segment.

Recognising these issues prevail in fishing as a whole, we do not identify a mechanism by which any option considered in the consultation could have a positive or negative effect on equality of opportunity for people based on their marriage or civil partnership status.

Promoting good relations among and between different age groups

No impact. This policy is not considered to have any positive or negative effect on promoting good relations between people with different marriage or civil partnership status.

Contact

Email: Accesstoseafisheries@gov.scot

Back to top