Statistical Bulletin: Crime and Justice Series: Criminal Appeal Statistics, Scotland: 2008-09

This bulletin presents statistics on criminal appeals concluded in the High Court of Justiciary and includes figures up to 2008-09.


5 Original Disposals and Outcomes of Criminal Appeals

Table 4 shows that the total of 2,191 concluded appeals in 2008-09 was equivalent to 2 per cent of the total number of persons with a charge proved in criminal proceedings in 2007-08.

There were 1,513 appeals concluded where the original disposal was custodial. This is equivalent to 9 per cent of the number of persons with a charge proved in 2007-08 who received a custodial disposal. A further breakdown of custodial disposals reveals that the percentage increases with sentence length: 5 per cent for sentences up to 6 months compared to 50 per cent for sentences of 4 years and over.

For each of the other disposal types, including financial penalties and community sentences, the number of appeals was equivalent to 1 per cent or less of the number of persons with a charge proved in 2007-08.

Table 4 Criminal appeals by main crime and disposal under appeal: 2008-09

Disposal before appeal

Number

Percentage of persons with a charge proved (2)(3)

All
crimes and
offences (1)

Crimes
of
violence

Crimes
of
indecency

Crimes
of
dishonesty

Criminal
damage

Drug
offences

Other
crimes

Common
assault

Breach
of the
peace

Other
misc.
offences

Motor
vehicle
offences

All
crimes and
offences (1)

Total (4)

2,191

266

310

308

54

208

202

68

203

72

448

2

Custody (5)

1,513

251

224

263

40

192

171

55

128

39

123

9

Up to 6 months

621

11

74

156

16

41

106

25

83

19

80

5

>6 months to 2 years

445

63

72

82

15

57

46

18

36

11

43

16

> 2 to < 4 years

175

46

23

13

6

47

14

8

8

3

-

28

4 years & over (including life)

272

131

55

12

3

47

5

4

1

6

-

50

Community sentence

132

5

26

18

7

5

9

9

31

4

16

1

Financial penalty

420

3

32

16

6

6

6

2

31

22

296

1

Other sentence

45

2

16

2

-

1

6

1

8

4

5

*

- Nil * Less than 0.5
1. Includes type of offence not known.
2. Percentages based on the number of persons with a charge proved in 2007/08.
3. The datasets used to calculate this percentage use different methodologies to identify main crime, therefore it is not possible to provide percentages for each crime type.
4. Includes disposal not known.
5. Includes sentence length not known.

Chart 5 and Table 5 provide information on the outcome of appeals. Of the total number of appeals concluded in 2008-09, 53 per cent (1155 appeals) were refused at the sift stage or abandoned. This is the lowest percentage since 2004-05 and a decrease of 8 percentage points from 2007-08.

A further 22 per cent (476 appeals) were dismissed. This is the highest percentage since 2004-05 and an increase of 7 percentage points from 2007-08.

The remaining 25 per cent (559 appeals) were sustained, a similar percentage to that recorded in the previous four years.

Chart 5 Criminal appeals by type of court of first instance and percentage outcome: 2008-09

Chart 5 Criminal appeals by type of court of first instance and percentage outcome: 2008-09

Table 5 Criminal appeals by outcome: 1999-00 to 2008-09

Year

Number

Percentage of total

Total (1)

Appeal sustained

Dismissed

Abandoned (3)

Appeal sustained

Dismissed

Abandoned (3)

Conviction (2)

Sentence

Conviction (2)

Sentence

1999-00

3,414

58

375

627

2,337

2

11

18

68

2000-01

3,204

49

318

694

2,137

2

10

22

67

2001-02

3,249

87

384

609

2,167

3

12

19

67

2002-03

2,156

69

346

435

1,302

3

16

20

60

2003-04

2,679

111

422

542

1,604

4

16

20

60

2004-05

3,152

174

722

788

1,468

6

23

25

47

2005-06

2,825

151

598

519

1,557

5

21

18

55

2006-07

2,118

96

350

316

1,353

5

17

15

64

2007-08

2,254

76

462

339

1,376

3

20

15

61

2008-09

2,191

120

439

476

1,155

5

20

22

53

1. Includes a small number of other sustained appeals.
2. Includes appeals against conviction and sentence.
3. Includes appeals refused at sift stage.

Back to top