The Cooperative Participatory Evaluation of Renewable Technologies on Ecosystem Services (CORPORATES): Scottish Marine and Freshwater Science Vol 7 No 1

This report provides the background, the process and the outcomes of an interdisciplinary project entitled “The Cooperative Participatory Evaluation of Renewable Technologies on Ecosystem Services: CORPORATES”, funded by the UK Natural Environment Resear


Appendix 1: Full list of Benefits from Workshop 1 Exercise 2

Benefit Code FINAL

Benefit - Participant Identified

Sector

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Contribute to local economy

Fishing/Maritime

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Food exports

Fishing/Maritime

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Tourist industry & employment

Fishing/Maritime

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Infrastructure associated to renewables ( e.g. Fife Energy Park)

Renewables

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Economy

Recreation & Tourism

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Tourism & economic

Recreation & Tourism

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Wealth - via property prices

Recreation & Tourism

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Wildlife tourism (Isle of May/Bass Rock)

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B1 Local Economic Benefit

(Marine) Tourism

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Coastal communities (and impacts on all marine incomes e.g. fisheries tourism)

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Recreational (enjoyment/revenue)

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Commercial fisheries

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Develop an offshore wind industry and infrastructure in Scotland

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B1 Local Economic Benefit

MPAs increase commercial fish stocks (potentially)

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Jobs and investment

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Develop an offshore wind industry and infrastructure in Scotland

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B1 Local Economic Benefit

Coastal communities (and impacts on all marine incomes e.g. fisheries tourism)

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B2 Employment

Employment opportunities

Fishing/Maritime

B2 Employment

Provision of employment

Fishing/Maritime

B2 Employment

Use of natural resources to make a living

Fishing/Maritime

B2 Employment

Employment in infrastructure

Fishing/Maritime

B2 Employment

Job creation (operation, manufacturing, maintenance)

Renewables

B2 Employment

Employment/ Job creation

Recreation & Tourism

B2 Employment

Jobs and investment

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B2 Employment

Tourist industry & employment

Fishing/Maritime

B3 Cultural Heritage

Family continuity

Fishing/Maritime

B3 Cultural Heritage

Daily life in peripheral communities

Fishing/Maritime

B3 Cultural Heritage

Historical markets: Spectacle in modern times - Tourist attraction

Fishing/Maritime

B3 Cultural Heritage

Cultural heritage

Fishing/Maritime

B3 Cultural Heritage

Fishing catch as local delicacy

Fishing/Maritime

B3 Cultural Heritage

Salmon & Sea trout as cultural heritage

Fishing/Maritime

B3 Cultural Heritage

Scotland's history

Fishing/Maritime

B3 Cultural Heritage

Community preservation/sense of community

Fishing/Maritime

B3 Cultural Heritage

Understanding heritage

Recreation & Tourism

B3 Cultural Heritage

History (uncovering history)/ Natural history awareness

Recreation & Tourism

B4 Social Bonding

Friendships (working with groups on projects)

Recreation & Tourism

B4 Social Bonding

Shared experience

Recreation & Tourism

B4 Social Bonding

Long term friends

Recreation & Tourism

B4 Social Bonding

Social interactions/development

Recreation & Tourism

B4 Social Bonding

Youth activities

Recreation & Tourism

B5 Healthy Climate

Reduction of carbon emissions

Renewables

B5 Healthy Climate

Contribution towards mitigation of climate change

Renewables

B5 Healthy Climate

Weather event

Recreation & Tourism

B5 Healthy Climate

Seasonal

Recreation & Tourism

B5 Healthy Climate

Renewable electricity

Recreation & Tourism

B5 Healthy Climate

Low carbon energy

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B5 Healthy Climate

Carbon cycling and sequestration

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B5 Healthy Climate

Carbon cycling and sequestration

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B5 Healthy Climate

Renewable energy generation

Renewables

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Renewable energy generation

Renewables

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Resilience

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Ecosystem resilience

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Healthy food webs for food production/Trophic functioning

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Food production for fish and shellfish

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Sense of place (importance of habitats to local populations

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Fishing ban (sand eels benefit)

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Designated area protection provides protection

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Sand eels feeding seabirds

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Food availability

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Suitable nesting habitat

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Estuarine habitat and food shelter

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Current patterns of food availability and diversity in area

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

MPAs increase commercial fish stocks (potentially)

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Current patterns of food availability and diversity in area

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Sand eels good habitat availability

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Resilience

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B6 Ecosystem Health and Resilience

Ecosystem resilience

Conservation & Ecological (Animal)

B7 Escape

Freedom/Escape

Recreation & Tourism

B7 Escape

Get away from man made things

Recreation & Tourism

B7 Escape

Relaxation/Calm/Enjoyment/Leave problems behind

Recreation & Tourism

B8 Health

Feel good factor/satisfaction - My hobby is my work

Fishing/Maritime

B8 Health

Food provision

Fishing/Maritime

B8 Health

Food as a nutrition

Fishing/Maritime

B8 Health

Salmon & Sea trout food

Fishing/Maritime

B8 Health

Relaxation/Calm/Enjoyment/Leave problems behind

Recreation & Tourism

B8 Health

Fitness/physical fitness

Recreation & Tourism

B8 Health

Well-being/ Spiritual wellbeing

Recreation & Tourism

B8 Health

Health/fresh air

Recreation & Tourism

B8 Health

Mental challenge/Good for your soul

Recreation & Tourism

B8 Health

Food

Recreation & Tourism

B8 Health

Enjoyment of the natural world

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B8 Health

Feel good factor/satisfaction - My hobby is my work

Fishing/Maritime

B9 Adventure and challenge

Salmon & Sea trout recreation

Fishing/Maritime

B9 Adventure and challenge

Testing your limits

Recreation & Tourism

B9 Adventure and challenge

Adventure

Recreation & Tourism

B9 Adventure and challenge

Sporting success

Recreation & Tourism

B9 Adventure and challenge

Recreational fishing

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B10 Knowledge and skills

Learning about immediate environment

Fishing/Maritime

B10 Knowledge and skills

Environmental data generated through the EIA process

Renewables

B10 Knowledge and skills

Education/Knowledge

Recreation & Tourism

B10 Knowledge and skills

Contributing to Science/research/academic study into ecological receptors

Recreation & Tourism

B10 Knowledge and skills

Personal development

Recreation & Tourism

B10 Knowledge and skills

Introduces people to new activities and environments

Recreation & Tourism

B10 Knowledge and skills

History (uncovering history)/ Natural history awareness

Recreation & Tourism

B10 Knowledge and skills

Play with boys toys (underwater photography)

Recreation & Tourism

B10 Knowledge and skills

Human geological study through protection

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B10 Knowledge and skills

Study benefits of MPA protection

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

B10 Knowledge and skills

Understanding heritage

Recreation & Tourism

B10 Knowledge and skills

Learning about immediate environment

Fishing/Maritime

B10 Knowledge and skills

Environmental data generated through the EIA process

Renewables

B11 Connection to Nature

Environmental appreciation

Recreation & Tourism

B11 Connection to Nature

Nature/Closeness to nature

Recreation & Tourism

B11 Connection to Nature

Experience natural environment

Recreation & Tourism

B11 Connection to Nature

Closeness to nature

Recreation & Tourism

B12 Aesthetics and Scenery

Enjoying the scenery

Recreation & Tourism

B12 Aesthetics and Scenery

Aesthetics

Conservation & Ecological (Human)

Contact

Back to top